‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ Review: Show Surpasses Films (2024)

“Look, I didn’t want to be a half-blood.”

Writer Rick Riordan became a household name in children’s fantasy literature when he debuted the first of six novels of the “Percy Jackson and the Olympians” series in 2005. Beginning with “The Lightning Thief,” readers grew to understand the struggles of 12-year-old Percy Jackson, a demigod whose human mother fell in love with an unknown god and raised Percy on her own. As young Percy discovered who he was, where he came from and the supernatural abilities he possessed, he began an immense quest.

Riordan’s novels were adapted for the silver screen in the mid-2010s, with actor Logan Lerman in the titular role as Percy Jackson. The film saga resulted in two motion pictures that grossed a total of $428 million at the box office, leaving room for an audience to consume more stories in ancient Greek mythology. Ten years later, and through the use of streaming television and updated visual effects, Percy Jackson lives on.

Disney+’s “Percy Jackson and the Olympians” stays faithful to its source material while giving the middle schooler some time to exist in the modern world. Walker Scobell (“The Adam Project”) takes on the reign of the half-god-half-human role as Percy Jackson defies the odds to uncover his family’s deepest secrets. Chief among them is an admission from his mother, Sally (Virginia Kull), that Percy is a demigod. Brought up with no knowledge of his father’s identity or whereabouts, Percy has low self-esteem and no friends, leading to problems standing up to bullies and those who don’t understand him.

‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ Review: Show Surpasses Films (1)

He takes solace in one classmate, Grover (Aryan Simhadri), who is quickly outed as a satyr. It turns out that discovering his best friend is half-horse is only one of many revelations young Percy encounters outside school grounds. In fact, a dangerous element is out to get Mr. Jackson, which materializes in the form of a math teacher (Megan Mullally) secretly attempting to harm him. Being a half-blood is dangerous, and most of the time, it gets one killed. Once Percy comprehends what he is, those serving Hades will also sense it and come for him.

The danger comes to a head when Percy’s mother explains everything to her young son, blowing his mind and changing everything he’s known as fact. An epic battle with a minotaur results in his mother disappearing and Percy killing the creature. To fend off the terrible forces looking to kill him, he hides in a camp for half-gods where he can be safe and adapt to his newfound powers.

At this camp, Percy uncovers the truths that have been carefully hidden from him throughout his life. His professor, Mr. Bruner, is actually a centaur. There are 12 Houses at the camp representing the 12 Olympians of Greek mythology, and that mythology is not just the stuff of ancient legends. He also finds comfort in other young campers, who’ve experienced the same struggles to fit in growing up. Making friends was never an easy feat for Percy, but at this camp, he is successful.

‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ Review: Show Surpasses Films (2)

But not everyone believes Percy is who he says he is. Annabeth (Leah Sava Jeffries) is a camp superstar and the daughter of Athena. A fierce warrior in her own right, Annabeth challenges Percy’s every move, leading the 12-year-old to realize what he’s good at and what he’s not. Annabeth recruits Percy to be on her team for Capture the Flag, though he still needs to learn where he fits in the game and in life. But Annabeth has a clue, and through the use of some ingenuity, the entire camp finds out that Percy Jackson is actually the son of Poseidon, god of the sea.

Through monumental visual effects and a captivating story that will entertain even the casual young observer, “Percy Jackson and the Olympians” is a win for Disney+. Percy’s father needs his son’s help returning a bolt to Zeus, which is most likely held captive along with Percy’s mother by Hades in the Underworld. The world’s fate hangs in the balance, and it is with this quest that Percy must prove his talents and rescue his mother from the clutches of pure evil.

The character of Percy Jackson has seen his time in the spotlight through Riordan’s books and the film adaptations that brought Logan Lerman some attention. This television adaptation borrows much of the same storylines Riordan wrote about in “The Lightning Thief,” introducing characters to a younger generation while holding true to the components that make Percy Jackson an entity worth rooting for. The writing in the two episodes available for review, by series co-creator Jonathan E. Steinberg, is quick-witted, the action is stellar, and making Percy’s journey an episodic tale helps to propel the young character forward in exciting directions.

Read Next
Will the Disney+ 'Percy Jackson' Series Incorporate the New Books? Author Rick Riordan Weighs In

Walker Scobell embodies a bullied pre-teen looking for solace and friendship that grounds “Percy Jackson and the Olympians” in an authentic way. Simultaneously discovering oneself and one’s abilities is a time-honored tradition of puberty shown on screen, but it doesn’t feel heavy-handed here. Percy’s plight and promises to his parents are genuine and surreal, leaving room for supporting characters to shine alongside the young demigod. This new adaptation is more of an ensemble than a one-person band, and it shows with the casting of all the supporting players.

Though “Percy Jackson and the Olympians” doesn’t break new ground for a character that’s been remade in popular culture several times over the past two decades, it gives new light to a beautiful story meant for younger viewers. Outstanding character development and enthralling personalities help build the television series to new heights. If the show succeeds with audiences, the other books in Rick Riordan’s canon might follow suit as the basis for additional seasons.

For Percy Jackson’s sake, let’s hope that’s the case.

“Percy Jackson and the Olympians” premieres with the first two episodes Wednesday, Dec. 20, on Disney+. Episode 1 will also be available to stream on Hulu.

‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ Review: Show Surpasses Films (2024)

FAQs

Will the Percy Jackson series be better than the movies? ›

Many are relieved it is better than the movies, as most of the fandom, including the author, have agreed the movies were abysmal. However, the TV series is not much better. One of the biggest flaws in the show is the run time for each episode, which averages about 35 minutes.

Was Percy Jackson TV show successful? ›

Percy Jackson and the Olympians marks the first time that Disney+ has found extended breakout success with something other than its Star Wars and Marvel properties.

Why didn t the Percy Jackson movies do well? ›

The films managed to fumble the series' plot so badly that it is almost unrecognizable, making the new Disney+ series better by default by even attempting to be faithful to the Percy Jackson books. The Lightning Thief reveals Camp Half-Blood's betrayer far too soon.

Are Percy Jackson books better than movies? ›

The 2010 movie and its 2013 sequel were both roundly rejected by fans of the books, who already far prefer the new show. Percy Jackson and the Olympians is categorically better than its cinematic counterparts, doing countless things better in its adaptation of The Lightning Thief.

Does the Percy Jackson series follow the movies? ›

There are many, many differences between the 2010s big-screen adaptations of Percy Jackson and the forthcoming 2023 Disney+ series. In part, this is because the Disney+ series aims to be a much more faithful adaptation of the source material than was managed by the 2010s movies.

Why did they make more Percy Jackson movies? ›

Percy Jackson 3 never became a reality because the second film, Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters, proved a commercial and critical disaster. The first two Percy Jackson movies received audience scores in the low 50s, according to Rotten Tomatoes, but all could have been forgiven with better sequels.

Why did they cancel Percy Jackson? ›

Percy Jackson movies disappointed fans and performed poorly at the box office, leading to the abandonment of Percy Jackson 3. The Percy Jackson TV show on Disney+ offers a chance for a faithful adaptation of the books, with the author's involvement ensuring a true-to-source material approach.

How much money did Rick Riordan make off of Percy Jackson? ›

Percy Jackson series earnings

Since 2010, Rick Riordan has earned over $103 million from bookselling, making him the 12th highest-paid author during this time. Riordan revealed that his books generated more revenue in the USA alone than both Percy Jackson movies grossed worldwide, which is over $426.3 million.

What do people think of the Percy Jackson series? ›

The effects and look of the series were well done. My problem was the series felt very rushed. After seeing the entire series I feel it could have been 2-5 episodes longer to supply more detail, build the world out, raise the stakes and allow us to get to know what's at stake.

Why was there no 3rd Percy Jackson movie? ›

In terms of revenue, the first Percy Jackson movie did very well, grossing $226.4 million worldwide. The second one made less, bringing in $199 million at the worldwide box office. It was clear that the brand would keep losing money with each entry, like what happened with the Narnia films.

Do Percy Jackson fans like the show? ›

Fans already liked the show better despite it not yet being released, simply because the author was writing it. That means that the core ideas and characters of the book would stay the same. The casting is also very good.

Why did they change Percy Jackson series so much? ›

Speaking with The Direct, Steinberg revealed why the changes they made to the Disney+ adaptation from the books were warranted. "A million changes and you hope that almost all of them are invisible. These are very different mediums, and I think they tell stories differently," he explained.

Which is more popular Harry Potter or Percy Jackson? ›

In the US Percy Jackson is much more popular whereas in the UK its Harry Potter. Moreover, there are more Harry Potter readers in total than Percy Jackson since HP was first published in 1997 and it became bestseller from that time.

Is Percy Jackson or Harry Potter easier to read? ›

I really enjoyed both of these writing styles but Rick Riordan, the author of the Percy Jackson series, has a light-hearted and digestible writing style which makes it easier for a wider audience to understand and enjoy the books.

Did Percy fight Annabeth in the books? ›

Annabeth first meets Percy when she was nursing him back to health after the encounter with the Minotaur. Annabeth first sees Percy when Grover was showing him around the camp. Percy and Annabeth encounter each other a second time when they fight each other in Capture The Flag.

Is the Percy Jackson series different from the movies? ›

The movies cut out important elements of Percy's character, such as his struggles with controlling his demi-god powers and his representation of dyslexia and ADHD, which were very significant in the books.

Is Percy Jackson series same as movies? ›

The “Percy Jackson” movies had some of the same characters and plot points, that bore some resemblance to the books they were “based” on, but in reality the plots couldn't have been more different.

Will the Percy Jackson series be like the books? ›

As is the case with all book-to-screen adaptations, Percy Jackson and the Olympians deviates occasionally from the source material. However, the main arc of the series remains the same: 12-year-old Percy Jackson (Walker Scobell) learns that he's a demigod, the son of a human woman and a Greek god.

Is Percy Jackson book series worth reading? ›

I would say yes. I think it holds up a lot better than many of its YA contemporaries. If you do decide to start reading it, I would suggest only reading the 5 Percy Jackson books and 3 Kane Chronicles books.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Eusebia Nader

Last Updated:

Views: 5585

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Eusebia Nader

Birthday: 1994-11-11

Address: Apt. 721 977 Ebert Meadows, Jereville, GA 73618-6603

Phone: +2316203969400

Job: International Farming Consultant

Hobby: Reading, Photography, Shooting, Singing, Magic, Kayaking, Mushroom hunting

Introduction: My name is Eusebia Nader, I am a encouraging, brainy, lively, nice, famous, healthy, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.